XII Review Scores

Home Forums Ganymede & Titan Forum XII Review Scores

This topic contains 16 replies, has 10 voices, and was last updated by  International Debris 5 days, 9 hours ago.

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)

Jump to bottom

  • Author
    Posts
  • #223179

    Stephen Abootman

    After the resounding success of my XI reviews thread, I thought I’d do another (AKA killing time whilst waiting for the Dwarfcast to start).

    CURED

    Flickeringmyth: 8/10
    Mymbuzz: 3.5/5
    Screenmayhem: 3.5/5
    Thepalaceofwisdom: 8/10
    Scifibulletin: 7/10
    Cultfix: 8/10
    38/50 (45/60)
    Average (out of 10): 7.5

    SILICONIA

    Flickeringmyth: 7/10
    Mymbuzz: 3/5
    Screenmayhem: 4.5/5
    Thepalaceofwisdom: 10/10
    Scifibulletin: 7/10
    Cultfix: 9/10
    40.5/50 (48/60)
    Average (out of 10): 8.0

    #223180

    Pete Part Three

    I swear you’re making some of these sites up, Stephen.

    #223181

    Stephen Abootman

    I could try NME but I think they’ve got bigger fish to fry.
    Actually, these days they probably haven’t.

    #223183

    flanl3

    I can’t wait for the Timewave ones so that I know which sites have opinions worth listening to.

    #223186

    Ben Saunders

    It’s much more interesting to read/listen to people you don’t agree with, though. It can either make you appreciate things you never did, see things from a different perspective, or want to strangle the person having such an egregious opinion.

    #223187

    GlenTokyo

    Timewave is irreparably damaged by unnecessarily offensive “jokes”.

    Sure it looks nice in places, Rimmer has a few good bits but you know what, Animal Hospital was a good TV show, and Jim’ll Fix It has a really good theme tune, but Animal Hospital isn’t repeated, and any ‘Top Retro TV Tunes’ rundown that actually wants to see the light of day will omit it.

    Truly bad, offensive writing is a new red sock in the white wash, whether you’ve got six pairs or one straggler, your clothes are fucked.

    *Yewtree reference not sponsored by Doug Naylor

    I’m strongly of the opinion that Timewave is empirically awful so it’ll be interesting to see how people “in the biz” see it.

    #223188

    flanl3

    Anybody who liked Timewave is probably just an old man who wants all the kids off his lawn, despite the fact that the kids are all, in fact, on their own lawns.

    #223190

    Ian Symes

    G&T Admin

    Careful about giving too much away in the forum, chaps – it’s fine so far, but strictly speaking it should be confined to threads with blue banners.

    #223193

    si

    I was reading the Radio Times’ preview of Timewave last night.
    “It would be a fool who has a bad word to say about tonight’s parable on free speech and political correctness.”

    So there. Fools.

    #223308

    KyoSo

    But the actual quality of jokes was far, far below the standard set by these past few series. As early as the Starbug mid-section scene I felt like something was distinctly “off” about the writing.

    #223375

    NoFro

    Yep. It was underwhelming from the off but got so much worse.

    #223393

    Stephen Abootman

    TIMEWAVE:

    Flickeringmyth: 4/10
    Mymbuzz: 4/5
    Screenmayhem: 3.5/5
    Thepalaceofwisdom: 6.5/10
    Scifibulletin: 7/10
    Cultfix: 8/10
    33/50 (40.5/60)
    Average (out of 10): 6.75

    The first episode of XI or XII to drop below a 7 average.

    #223450

    KyoSo

    Must be homophobia against Ziggy and his campy antics. I can’t imagine any other reason Timewave would earn a lower score.

    #224347

    Stephen Abootman

    MECHOCRACY:

    Flickeringmyth: 8/10
    Mymbuzz: 4.5/5
    Screenmayhem: 5/5
    Thepalaceofwisdom: 9/10
    Scifibulletin: 9/10
    Cultfix: 9/10
    44.5/50 (54/60)
    Average (out of 10): 9.0

    M-CORP:

    Flickeringmyth: 7/10
    Mymbuzz: 3.5/5
    Screenmayhem: 4/5
    Thepalaceofwisdom: 8.5/10
    Scifibulletin: 9/10
    Cultfix: 9/10
    41/50 (48.5/60)
    Average (out of 10): 8.1

    #224361

    Ben Saunders

    Sounds about right

    #224823

    Stephen Abootman

    SKIPPER:

    Flickeringmyth: 9/10
    Mymbuzz: 4/5 (they’ve put 4.5 for long term fans, 3.5 for others so splitting the difference)
    Screenmayhem: 4.5/5
    Thepalaceofwisdom: 10/10
    Scifibulletin: 8/10
    Cultfix: 10/10
    45.5/50 (54/60)
    Average (out of 10): 9.0

    The XI & XII Leaderboard:
    1) Skipper: 9.0
    2) Mechocracy: 9.0
    3) Give and Take: 8.58
    4) M-Corp: 8.1
    5) Siliconia: 8.0
    6) Officer Rimmer: 8.0
    7) Can of Worms 7.83
    8) Krysis: 7.83
    9) Twentica: 7.67
    10) Cured: 7.5
    11) Samsara: 7.25
    12) Timewave: 6.75

    #224824

    International Debris

    Well the top 6 there would be my ‘one series’ version of XI & XII (hard as it would be to lose Krysis), so I can’t argue with that really.

Jump to top / Jump to 'Recent Replies'

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Comments are closed.