Home › Forums › Ganymede & Titan Forum › Red Dwarf: Titan speculation thread

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #291585
    Spare Hand One
    Participant

    How is there no thread for this already? I’m so sorry if I’ve missed one like an absolute gimboid git.

    Has there yet been any speculation about RD:TIT (as the cool kids and Trek fans call it) being a female-led reboot? “One universe over” could be Arlene and Deb’s universe, no? And didn’t Rob already cast female fans for Into the Goop?

Viewing 50 replies - 1 through 50 (of 65 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #291586
    Flap Jack
    Participant

    I’d say it’s a combination of people already getting out their initial speculations in the comments of the news article about it, and that a dedicated speculation thread for a series which hasn’t even commissioned yet is possibly tempting fate – I’m sure we had a Series XIII speculation thread, and look what happened there.

    #291589
    Moonlight
    Participant

    To be fair, I blame Doug for that comment to the effect of “If I were a betting man, at least two more series” while XI and XII were happening. I genuinely thought for a while there was a chance we’d get four years of new Red Dwarf in a row.

    #291591

    Doug cant even get bets right when he has insider information!

    #291592
    loadoftottnumb
    Participant

    Yeah very difficult to speculate at this stage but it’s an internet forum so fuck it I’ll charge in. 

    I reckon the cast will be something like 

    Dave Lister: Younger actor resembling Craig Charles 

    Arnold Rimmer: Younger actor resembling Chris Barrie 

    K/Christine Kochanski: As above, resembling Annett/Grogan

    Holly: Female version, younger Hattie (I would POP if it was actually Hattie) 

    “Cat”: A character that resembles and acts like a young DJJ, but isn’t actually a cat. He could be called that though, short for ‘Carton’ or something. 

    “Kryten” A mechanoid of some kind similar to old bog bot. 

    We will likely see some other pre-accident friends like Hollister, McGruder and Petersen too. Maybe a female Hollister. 

    I predict it will be a bigger/broader cast of characters than we are used to in most RD instances, though the story will focus on Rimmer and Lister. 

    There will of course be some brand new, unseen characters, particularly the antagonists. Knowing Rob’s solo Dwarf probably flesh eating, baby drowning, pot noodle eating Nazis. 

    #291593
    Ridley
    Participant

    Five specs of TIT

    #291595
    Moonlight
    Participant

    10 dollarpounds says the first episode is called “Vagina Destroyer”.

    #291689
    Spare Hand One
    Participant

    I’m glad there’s a bit of speculation here now. Thought at first it was a black card situation.

    I think the cameos from the original cast should (and will) be quite small. I think at most they’ll be Jim Reaper/Data Doctor-type appearances, which I don’t wholly object to but I could live without. I like the fresh startness of this whole idea. I don’t think Cat or Kryten should be in this at all, especially not Cat. Maybe a Kryten plotline could happen in parallel, he getting snapped up to serve on the Nova 5 or something, but I don’t think that’s necessary either. Would be happy to have KK and Peterson et al in it though. And a sky full of Red Dwarf in orbit would be quite striking.

    I’m also gunning for this being Arlene and Deb’s dimension. I doubt this is Rob’s plan but I think it would would be sweet.

    #291690
    Flap Jack
    Participant

    Both Young Rimmer and Young Lister will be killed in the first episode, paving the way for Trixie LaBouche to become the lead character. The series will cover her misadventures in Titan’s criminal underworld, and her unlikely partnership with Dwayne Dibbley (who is a real guy, unlike Duane Dibbley).

    #291691
    si
    Participant

    Oh God, I’d love to see Trixie LaBouche as a lead character. 

    #291692

    A series about Rimmer in Trixie LaBouche’s body, let’s see what Rob’s learned from Twitter.

    #291695
    Moonlight
    Participant

    John Ewe’s Revenge

    #291792
    Warbodog
    Participant

    Started watching Attack on Titan. Turns out it’s not about Titan.

    #291793
    Moonlight
    Participant

    Attack on Titan lost me as soon as I realized it was going to be about regular sized people jumping around to fight the titans. It just completely blew everything about the concept and world I found engaging. It’s like, oh here’s this creepy, unstoppable, titanic force of nature we just have to live with, but actually you can beat them up. It’s fine.

    #291796
    Unrumble
    Participant

    Maybe Derek Custer and Kit will make an appearance…

    #309103
    Cardinal_Hordriss
    Participant

    Is this project dead?

    #309104
    Dax101
    Participant

    Rob Grant says they are currently trying to get funding. So who knows whats going on.

    #309105
    Rushy
    Participant

    I would assume so. 

    Doug constantly has an uphill battle getting the actual main show made. So how is Rob – who hasn’t been a serious part of the industry in decades – going to produce a prequel?

    #309112

    I don’t think a less true statement has been written on this forum than Rob “Hasn’t been a serious part of the industry in decades” 

    #309113
    Moonlight
    Participant

    Fair point that the main show is hard enough to get made, but Rob has been working this whole time.

    #309114
    Rushy
    Participant

    I’m not sure that four books and three seasons of radio dramas over 25 years counts as being an active member of the industry. It’s not going to entice anyone to trust him with a new television series for the first time since 1993. 

    #309115
    Dax101
    Participant

    Its probably got less to do with trust and more to do with the brand. Rob doesn’t need to have worked on the show in the last 25 years to be able to pitch new Red Dwarf. A show that has a fandom and a legacy attached to it. And only Rob and Doug have that control to create new material for it. So why wouldn’t you trust the co-creator with the show?

    Rob did Dark Ages and the Strangerers too. So in terms of what that means for industry clout, its probably not all that different from Doug.

    Its all going to come down to value as to whether any Red Dwarf gets made.

    #309116
    Rushy
    Participant

    But would you really listen to someone who hasn’t produced, written or directed a single episode of television in a quarter of a century? 

    It’s not even just about clout, but also keeping up with the evolution of live-action media production and building relationships with other professionals. Doug has a well-oiled team behind him, he’s kept himself up to date, he’s constantly working on producing more content and honing the presentation of the show. Even that tweet about wanting the fancy new camera is telling. 

    At the risk of sounding mean – as a TV executive, why would I listen to a pitch from Rob Grant when I can just ask him for Doug Naylor’s phone number? If I’m willing to hear about a new Red Dwarf show, I’d like to talk to the person who makes Red Dwarf. 

    #309118
    RunawayTrain
    Participant

    But would you really listen to someone who hasn’t produced, written or directed a single episode of television in a quarter of a century? 

    It’s not even just about clout, but also keeping up with the evolution of live-action media production and building relationships with other professionals. Doug has a well-oiled team behind him, he’s kept himself up to date, he’s constantly working on producing more content and honing the presentation of the show. Even that tweet about wanting the fancy new camera is telling. 
    At the risk of sounding mean – as a TV executive, why would I listen to a pitch from Rob Grant when I can just ask him for Doug Naylor’s phone number? If I’m willing to hear about a new Red Dwarf show, I’d like to talk to the person who makes Red Dwarf. 

    But who says Rob Grant doesn’t have connections with people currently still active?  Who says he doesn’t have people in the industry already willing to work on it if it can get off the ground?  

    BIB in the last paragraph – it would be a little silly to think he hasn’t considered that for pitching anything.  

    Of course I have no idea how likely it is that either one of them will get anything commissioned.  Just since we have no idea what might be happening that isn’t public knowledge or can be inferred from public knowledge, we really can’t assume anything either way.

    #309119
    Flap Jack
    Participant

    That is a bit harsh, Rushy. Was it even an essential part of the pitch for Titan that Rob directs and produces it personally? I don’t think Rob’s experience makes him underqualified to create and write for a Red Dwarf spin-off, when Red Dwarf is the main thing he’s known for.

    Plus, Doug got the Red Dwarf revival in spite of him not producing any TV shows for a decade. The gap is larger with Rob but it’s not like Doug was directing new shows every year and was up to date with all the industry minutae.

    As an aside Doug has never written a children’s book before, but a publisher still trusted him to do so.

    #309121
    Unrumble
    Participant

    Doug has a well-oiled team behind him

    #309122

    I’d say there probably is some truth to Rushy’s point that Rob will probably have a few more hurdles than Doug, especially given that his two solo shows aren’t exactly well remembered. Doug has a reasonably consistent run of TV production since 1993, whereas Rob has a couple of semi-obscure one-series flops made in 1999 & 2000 and nothing else.

    But he has worked with the BBC in recent years, and is the co-creator of a very popular and well-known brand that he’s trying to create a new series within, so I don’t think he’s going to struggle. Not for that reason, anyway. The main reason would be the British TV industry is in a dire state and creating anything remotely bold without a good amount of outside backing is next-to-impossible these days. If Actual Red Dwarf is struggling to be made then New Red Dwarf Spinoff is probably doing even worse. 

    #309128
    Dax101
    Participant

    Thing is when it comes to Doug’s chances vs Rob’s chances, its never going to come down to this idea that Doug kept the show going so he will be more trusted. Doug hasn’t done much outside of Red Dwarf so the fact he has a successful show comes down more to the fact that Red Dwarf is already a successful show. Its got an audience attached to it and to an extent can be sold over sea’s. So even if Rob Grant starting pitching a new Red Dwarf to whoever, no one is going to see his name as a value. Its going be “Red Dwarf” thats got the value.

    Id say the question is more does Doug have more connections in the industry than Rob due to having been working on Red Dwarf for so long.

    #309134
    Rushy
    Participant

    Doug hasn’t done much outside of Red Dwarf so the fact he has a successful show comes down more to the fact that Red Dwarf is already a successful show. Its got an audience attached to it and to an extent can be sold over sea’s. So even if Rob Grant starting pitching a new Red Dwarf to whoever, no one is going to see his name as a value. Its going be “Red Dwarf” thats got the value.

    But Red Dwarf today is Doug. It’s not really a 50/50 thing anymore. What would have been a beloved comedy classic has become a franchise that endures in the 21st century. That is Doug’s franchise, a house he built on the foundation of old Red Dwarf. The only reason we talk about spinoffs at all is because of Doug’s work with the Dave era. 

    Literally every official Red Dwarf product and project since the Backwards novel has been created at the instigation of Doug alone. With Rob involving himself whenever he feels like it. 

    As a businessman, it makes much more sense to help Doug produce new Red Dwarf or Red Dwarf-related ideas (stage show, movie etc.) than gambling on a semi-retired producer whose main legacy is mysteriously quitting the show 32 years ago. 

    #309143

    Again, incredible disservice to Rob who has a 40+ year career as a writer of comedy in radio, TV and books. Red Dwarf isn’t the only, thing he is known and remembered for.

    Doug has indeed kept Red Dwarf alive for the last couple of decades, but is entirely focused on a show that has an expiration date and one that has probably passed.

    If Rob comes up with a really good idea that is Red Dwarf adjacent a commissioner and investor likes then why wouldn’t they trust an experienced comedy writer to write it?

    that’s not to say I think it would happen. I just don’t think it won’t happen because Rob hasn’t written Red Dwarf since the 90s.

    If anything, his CV of other projects would demonstrate he can do something different with the idea, unlike Doug who has only written for the main premise for the majority of the last 37 years. 

    #309146
    Asclepius
    Participant

    Totally agree with Rushy on this one. Doug mightn’t have done anything than Red Dwarf for the past twenty years, but in that time he was produced Dave’s biggest ratings winners, and all of those episodes are also freely available on i-player.

    Rob’s done a couple of books that are presumably now out of print, and some Radio 4 series that aren’t accessible online, as far as I can tell. His last TV work was, when, 25 years ago? He’s going to have a long, uphill battle to get anything made.

    Doug, with his track record of managing to make 18 episodes of Red Dwarf and two specials since 2009, his ability to rely on the cast to still be involved, and his ability to rely on the well regarded Baby Cow to do some of the tricky bits means that he’s in a whole different world to Rob on this. And he’s *still* having trouble getting anything out.

    #309147
    Warbodog
    Participant

    Aww, but Rob’s buttski promised.

    #309152
    Dave
    Participant

    Literally every official Red Dwarf product and project since the Backwards novel has been created at the instigation of Doug alone.

    How soon we forget Into The Gloop

    #309159
    Asclepius
    Participant

    Literally every official Red Dwarf product and project since the Backwards novel has been created at the instigation of Doug alone.
    How soon we forget Into The Gloop

    My therapist suggests that doing just that is the best way forward.

    #309163
    Unrumble
    Participant

    #309165
    Spaceworm Jim
    Participant

    Isn’t the point that Red Dwarf as a brand is bigger than either Rob or Doug? In the UK, a lot of people know the show who don’t connect the name to Grant Naylor. Isn’t that the general audience potential commissioners would be thinking of?

    #309168
    Asclepius
    Participant

    Isn’t the point that Red Dwarf as a brand is bigger than either Rob or Doug? In the UK, a lot of people know the show who don’t connect the name to Grant Naylor. Isn’t that the general audience potential commissioners would be thinking of?

    It’s a big brand, but any broadcasters buying into it are going to look at how they’re dealing with. Look at the fuss Anthony Jay and Jonathan Lynn made in 2013 when they tried to bring Yes Prime Ministers back to TV by adapting their stage play. The BBC still wanted a pilot even though it was the same writers, but different actors. I imagine that Doug – the man who has written or co-written every episode of Red Dwarf, and has directed the bulk of the last 10/15 years of it, is going to fare better in those negotiations than Rob who hasn’t written for the show on TV in a third of a century.

    #309170
    Jenuall
    Participant

    Not everything has to be a Rob vs Doug debate guys!

    Lets face it – Red Dwarf, despite being a 30+ year franchise that has consistently performed well in terms of ratings, is always going to be something that struggles to get made for a whole host of reasons ranging from the classic “we don’t want sci-fi” angle, through the ever increasing challenge of organising and enabling a bunch of aging blokes to perform one more time, to the simple complexity that it represents as a production with its sets, props, effects, models etc.

    Doug having some recent leverage with Dave and Baby Cow is good, but only goes so far in terms of resolving the above.

    Rob on the other hand probably benefits from the fact that Titan (and whatever else he’s got lodged up his buttski) isn’t “Red Dwarf” as we know it – the fact it would be a different setting, cast, scenario etc. might allow it to be 1. more appealing to someone commissioning something new and 2. allow them to sidestep some of the production and logistical challenges of making traditional Dwarf.

    Basically whatever way you look at it anyone making something Dwarf or Dwarf-adjacent is going to have a hard time!

    #309172
    Jenuall
    Participant

    Wait, I forgot the date, as you were.

    #309174
    Rushy
    Participant

    allow them to sidestep some of the production and logistical challenges of making traditional Dwarf. 

    Unless they’re making radio dramas or books, it’s going to be more expensive than a crammed studio sitcom. This is still a sci-fi universe, after all. An animated production would be more expensive. A new TV show would definitely be more expensive. 

    Let’s not forget that Back to Earth and series 10 were made for less money than series 1. You can’t really pinch more pennies than that. 

    #309175
    Dax101
    Participant

    Isn’t the point that Red Dwarf as a brand is bigger than either Rob or Doug? In the UK, a lot of people know the show who don’t connect the name to Grant Naylor. Isn’t that the general audience potential commissioners would be thinking of?

    Doug did a pilot for BBC1 in 2014, which didn’t really become a series. While you get something like Red Dwarf, lets say Back to earth which is not the most loved piece of Red Dwarf. But it had a loyal audience attached to it, and even at its weakest reception still allowed Doug to get another chance with Series X. If this wasn’t Red Dwarf that wouldn’t have happened. Back to earth would have been it for the show i believe.

    Red Dwarf was at its own successful in the 90s and now its very much an nostalgic show thats held together by legacy. 

    #309176
    Jenuall
    Participant

    #309178
    Moonlight
    Participant

    I know it’s supposed to not be great but I still want to see Over to Bill just to see it.

    #309185
    Cardinal_Hordriss
    Participant

    So, in answer to my question, am I to take it that opinion is somewhat divided?

    Lol.

    #309212
    Technopeasant
    Participant

    So, in answer to my question, am I to take it that opinion is somewhat divided?

    Lol.

    Not really, everyone seems to agree Red Dwarf is a pain in the ass.

    #309232
    MANI506
    Participant

    Did we miss the tenth anniversary of Over To Bill? I still want to see it if anyone knows where. 

    #309238
    clem
    Participant
    #309249
    Ben Saunders
    Participant

    Did we miss the tenth anniversary of Over To Bill?

    #309271
    MANI506
    Participant

    Here’s a clip 
    https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p01y8317

    Thank you! Upsettingly I’m only seven years younger than those two men.

    #309283
    Ian Symes
    Keymaster

    Aside from all the other things that everyone else has covered, it’s weird to assume that Red Dwarf: Titan would have to be a TV show. Rob’s relative lack of recent experience in television (although, as others have said, we don’t know whether Rob would have any production role other than writer, especially considering Paul and Ed are likely to be attached) wouldn’t be remotely an issue for a book or a radio series, both of which Rob has released in the last ten years.

    Personally, I think anyone – Rob, Doug, even miraculously Rob and Doug together – would struggle to get a scripted television project commissioned now. The TV industry is in a bad, bad way, nobody has the money to do it properly. But books, radio, comics, commercial audio (ie Big Finish or equivalents) are all up for grabs, and anything Dwarf-adjacent would be an attractive proposition for those commissioners. 

    #309284
    Flap Jack
    Participant

    We’re just assuming that it has to be an animation, to capitalise on the wild popularity of Red Christmas.

Viewing 50 replies - 1 through 50 (of 65 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.