Home Forums Ganymede & Titan Forum Series X US Re-release

Viewing 50 posts - 1 through 50 (of 64 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #264287
    thomasaevans
    Participant

    Series X has been re-released in the US on DVD from ‘BBC Archives’ (Interesting name). Virtually the same artwork. The previous release has been out of print for some time apparently.

    #264547
    Moonlight
    Participant

    For some reason, the American release of Series XI has a “The Complete Eleventh Series” label on it but Series X and XII don’t. Even more confusing is XII, which uses the same template for the cover as XI but has no “Complete Twelfth Series” text.

    It just seems utterly bizarre to not just not label them correctly but to label ONE OF THEM correctly but not the others. Normies getting into Red Dwarf probably don’t have a fucking clue what order the show goes in between that and BtE / TPL not having series numbers.

    #264548
    Flap Jack
    Participant

    It’s not just the US releases that make this mistake either. The UK DVD/Blu ray release of Back to Earth didn’t have “The Complete Ninth Series” on its cover, as we all know it should.

    #264549
    Dave
    Participant

    For some reason, the American release of Series XI has a “The Complete Eleventh Series” label on it but Series X and XII don’t.

    Well they wouldn’t, they’re the tenth and twelfth series.

    #264550
    Warbodog
    Participant

    Are normies not up on their Roman numerals I-XII? Selectively skipping numbers doesn’t help, but it’s just like having to know the order of any unnumbered film series or where The X-Files films fit in-between the seasons.

    I can imagine 90s kids being on the lookout for an elusive ‘IX’ video and not realising until later that it’s just BTE that they already have*, but that shouldn’t be an issue noawadays with an excessively detailed Wikipedia page and things.

    * If it had existed, Dave.

    #264551

    There is a bit of an issue sometimes with specials that they’re not listed chronologically with the metadata of the series so you reach the end of a series, then have to come out of it and search the special separately. Doctor Who used to be the worst for that, but at least now on iPlayer everything runs in order.

    And I’ve run into the issue where the Battlestar Galactica movies aren’t even hosted alongside the series so you can’t enjoy those at the same time.

    Things have gotten better on that front, but with a show like Red Dwarf that is hosted across different streaming services, it shouldn’t be the case that you have to have IMDB or Wikipedia open to know what to watch next.

    #264552
    Ridley
    Participant

    For some reason, the American release of Series XI has a “The Complete Eleventh Series” label on it but Series X and XII don’t.

    Well they wouldn’t, they’re the tenth and twelfth series.

    They’re on The Promised Land steelbook.

    #264553
    Flap Jack
    Participant

    Yes, if your primary method of watching new series Doctor Who is via digital versions on Amazon or iTunes, that is pain.

    Then again, even the DVD range fucks you around from time to time. Christmas specials are only included on the next full series box set if they share a Doctor, but for Time of the Doctor they force you to either double dip on 3 other Matt Smith Christmas specials or double dip on the series 7 finale. Still irritated about that.

    #264554
    Warbodog
    Participant

    I was thinking of BSG, I think a lot of people have tripped over the miniseries and start out confused at 1×01, since it’s classed as a different production.

    With TV spin-offs and cinematic universes, you’d want to keep track of release orders and what seasons were parallel to each other for broader continuity.

    That’s why I don’t think it’s especially an issue for Red Dwarf (so far), especially as there’s barely any continuity to worry about if you do get it wrong. You could assume you missed a series even when you didn’t.

    #264555
    Dave
    Participant

    I was thinking of BSG, I think a lot of people have tripped over the miniseries and start out confused at 1×01, since it’s classed as a different production.

    I did that with the DVDs. I foolishly started with Season One Episode 1, thinking it would be the first episode.

    #264556
    GlenTokyo
    Participant

    I think the shrinking appeal of physical copies means that the people that really like Red Dwarf enough to go and get or order the physical discs, will know what they’re after, and just be a little miffed at inconsistent labelling, but won’t miss out on any episodes.

    #264557

    I was thinking of BSG, I think a lot of people have tripped over the miniseries and start out confused at 1×01, since it’s classed as a different production.

    The number of times I have seen people have to state “start with the mini series”, it’s mind boggling that that has to be said. You could easily miss the first two episodes and jump straight in after the set up.

    I think the shrinking appeal of physical copies means that the people that really like Red Dwarf enough to go and get or order the physical discs, will know what they’re after, and just be a little miffed at inconsistent labelling, but won’t miss out on any episodes.

    Are the DVDs even sold this way?! I have the blu-ray boxset that includes EVERYTHING but I’d have thought a “complete season 1” DVD would include the “mini-series”. Do you have to buy that separately?

    I think luckily I have seen it in some places have the mini-series pushed as episodes 1 and 2, but it’s really pot luck what the streaming service decides or how a torrent is packaged etc.

    #264558
    GlenTokyo
    Participant

    Are the DVDs even sold this way?! I have the blu-ray boxset that includes EVERYTHING but I’d have thought a “complete season 1” DVD would include the “mini-series”. Do you have to buy that separately?

    I wouldn’t think that a complete Season 1 would include a separate mini series personally, not if it wasn’t broadcast at the same time or very, very, shortly after, so if I was aware of said mini series I’d assume I’d have to purchase it separately. They should probably do an ‘everything’ Red Dwarf boxset though. Maybe they’re just waiting for the cast to retire.

    #264559

    Are the DVDs even sold this way?! I have the blu-ray boxset that includes EVERYTHING but I’d have thought a “complete season 1” DVD would include the “mini-series”. Do you have to buy that separately?

    I wouldn’t think that a complete Season 1 would include a separate mini series personally, not if it wasn’t broadcast at the same time or very, very, shortly after, so if I was aware of said mini series I’d assume I’d have to purchase it separately. They should probably do an ‘everything’ Red Dwarf boxset though. Maybe they’re just waiting for the cast to retire.

    It’s fine if you know, but if like Dave you pick up series one and then find there’s actually episodes that come before it, it’d be a bit annoying.

    #264560
    Dave
    Participant

    Are the DVDs even sold this way?! I have the blu-ray boxset that includes EVERYTHING but I’d have thought a “complete season 1” DVD would include the “mini-series”. Do you have to buy that separately?

    On the initial release (that I bought) certainly the DVD boxset didn’t have the miniseries. I sat down to watch it and within about ten minutes realised I had to go order a separate DVD.

    #264622
    Ben Paddon
    Participant

    Every release of BSG Season 1 I’ve owned – and I’ve owned three from both the US and UK – has included the miniseries, starting at disc one. Am I missing something?

    #264624

    Am I missing something?

    No, but Dave is.

    #264626
    Dave
    Participant

    Every release of BSG Season 1 I’ve owned – and I’ve owned three from both the US and UK – has included the miniseries, starting at disc one. Am I missing something?

    I’m sure there have been other editions that included the miniseries too, but like I said, the version I unwittingly bought didn’t.

    I can’t be sure from memory but I think it was this version.

    A quick google seems to indicate that the initial season one DVD boxset for Region 1 included the miniseries, but for Region 2 it didn’t and you had to buy the DVD of the miniseries separately.

    You must have had a later version of the UK set that bundled the miniseries in too.

    #264647
    pfm
    Participant

    Anyone else wish they had made more of a thing of ‘head’ Baltar?

    #264648
    Nick R
    Participant

    I’m sure there have been other editions that included the miniseries too, but like I said, the version I unwittingly bought didn’t.
    I can’t be sure from memory but I think it was this version.

    A quick google seems to indicate that the initial season one DVD boxset for Region 1 included the miniseries, but for Region 2 it didn’t and you had to buy the DVD of the miniseries separately.
    You must have had a later version of the UK set that bundled the miniseries in too.

    Yeah, I first watched BSG via DVD rentals from LoveFilm*, and remember renting the miniseries and season 1 separately. (And later I had to be careful when to add Razor to my rental list. I don’t think I ever watched The Plan.) I later bought a cheap second-hand copy of season 1, and it was the edition in your Amazon link that didn’t include the miniseries.

    * RIP LoveFilm; long live Cinema Paradiso!

    #264650
    Warbodog
    Participant

    I don’t think I ever watched The Plan.

    You’ve already seen most of The Plan if you saw the series. The new material was mainly unconvincing bending of continuity jigsaw pieces to pretend there was a big picture, like the ‘What year did “The End” take place in?’ thread done seriously.

    But still more worthwhile than the rest of the franchise milking turned out to be.

    #264651
    Dave
    Participant

    You’ve already seen most of The Plan if you saw the series. The new material was mainly unconvincing bending of continuity jigsaw pieces to pretend there was a big picture, like the ‘What year did “The End” take place in?’ thread done seriously.

    Yeah, it was a bit of a disappointment in the end wasn’t it?

    #264727
    Warbodog
    Participant

    I’ve just gone and made the same mistake with Babylon 5. A few episodes into the famously long-form plotted TV novel, I found out I’d skipped over the pilot movie.

    I go back on what I said about checking wikis and things, because of the inevitable spoilers, even from seemingly innocuous things like cast photos/details. Worse would be asking for guidance and getting someone’s insane personal viewing order.

    Unrelated post from the Red Dwarf subreddit:

    I watch most of series 7 and 8 because of continuity errors when that doesn’t happen. First, I watch Tikka to Ride extended then imagine that the Infinity Patrol arrive and declare the timeline redundant due to the universe still sorting itself out, and everyone being sent back to the point where it all began, only with a few differences, to which I was the remasters versions.

    Then I skip back to Out of Time, switch to the deleted ending and, because the timelines converge, everyone now thinks that the series 1 Red Dwarf was the one they were using. I then replace Tikka with Identity Within, then proceed as normal, skipping Duct Soup and Beyond a Joke to maintain consistency with the other series.

    I still have to watch Epideme, but the plan is to watch Back in the Red Extended, Cassandra and Only the Good, with the alternate ending, then proceeding onto the revival.

    #264728
    Ian Symes
    Keymaster

    If you’re going to go to that effort, you’d be better off taking the “Nine Years Later” caption from the start of Back To Earth, and just watching that in place of any episodes you want to skip.

    #264729

    I’ve just gone and made the same mistake with Babylon 5. A few episodes into the famously long-form plotted TV novel, I found out I’d skipped over the pilot movie.

    I go back on what I said about checking wikis and things, because of the inevitable spoilers, even from seemingly innocuous things like cast photos/details. Worse would be asking for guidance and getting someone’s insane personal viewing order.
    Unrelated post from the Red Dwarf subreddit:
    I watch most of series 7 and 8 because of continuity errors when that doesn’t happen. First, I watch Tikka to Ride extended then imagine that the Infinity Patrol arrive and declare the timeline redundant due to the universe still sorting itself out, and everyone being sent back to the point where it all began, only with a few differences, to which I was the remasters versions.
    Then I skip back to Out of Time, switch to the deleted ending and, because the timelines converge, everyone now thinks that the series 1 Red Dwarf was the one they were using. I then replace Tikka with Identity Within, then proceed as normal, skipping Duct Soup and Beyond a Joke to maintain consistency with the other series.
    I still have to watch Epideme, but the plan is to watch Back in the Red Extended, Cassandra and Only the Good, with the alternate ending, then proceeding onto the revival.

    Fucking hell and I thought we were boring.

    Also, I tried Babylon 5, can’t remember if I had the movie or not to start it off? I assume so I just torrented the lot in one go but … I really really struggled and stopped at around episode 5 or 6. For a show made in the era of TNG and DS9 etc, it really felt like it was made a decade earlier. Wanted to like it because I’d heard so much good stuff but couldn’t get past the production.

    Even the scripting and the names/titles of things sorta all felt like someone writing sci-fi for the first time.

    #264731

    The first series is pretty patchy, and yes, it’s definitely smaller budget than the Trek of the same era, but it’s really worth sticking with. The third and fourth seasons are some of the best TV sci-fi ever made.

    #264733
    Warbodog
    Participant

    I find the whole 90s aesthetic charming, it’s just some of the acting I have to get past.

    #264735
    Jonathan Capps
    Keymaster

    Also, I tried Babylon 5, can’t remember if I had the movie or not to start it off? I assume so I just torrented the lot in one go but … I really really struggled and stopped at around episode 5 or 6. For a show made in the era of TNG and DS9 etc, it really felt like it was made a decade earlier. Wanted to like it because I’d heard so much good stuff but couldn’t get past the production.

    If you have the time what with the millions of other shit there is to watch these days, I highly recommend to give B5 a chance beyond the first season. It doesn’t just get good, it’s gets fucking good.

    #264737

    I hear what everyone is saying … I just loathing having to watch hours and hours of shit TV on the promise something gets better.

    But maybe I will again try at some point soon, I have precious little else on at the moment.

    #264742
    Jonathan Capps
    Keymaster

    I mean, season 1 isn’t shit. Not unless you believe those lying early 2000s comedies.

    #264745
    Ian Symes
    Keymaster

    Before lockdown, I worked in the same offices as Martin Trenaman. Every time I saw him, I was desperate to yell “Babylon 5’s a big pile of shit”.

    #264746
    Rudolph
    Participant

    With the Babylon 5 pilot movie, I really don’t think it’s essential to watch. All the important stuff it brings up is brought up in the series proper done a lot better.

    Watch it as a curio, but it doesn’t really add anything.

    #264754
    GlenTokyo
    Participant

    Disclaimer: I’ve never really seen Babylon 5

    #264755
    Warbodog
    Participant

    Neither had Simon Pegg, from what I remember of the audio commentary. It was just a good target to bring out the cult defensiveness and nothing personal.

    Never realised that was him from The Inbetweeners.

    #264768
    Ridley
    Participant

    Stargate SG-1’s better anyway.

    #264779
    RunawayTrain
    Participant

    Stargate SG-1’s better anyway.

    Whoop! Though funnily enough my box set doesn’t contain the original film … (I don’t remember off the top of my head how much ‘Children of the Gods’ explains for the first-time viewer.)

    #264780

    SG-1 doesn’t come close to Babylon 5, but it is a <i>lot</i> of fun.
    I’d almost recommend not watching the Stargate film, though, what with it having entirely different actors and some pretty different concepts, and being really, really, really bad.

    #264781
    Hamish
    Participant

    I rate the first season of Babylon 5 a lot higher than most, and it becomes only more impressive when you learn what Michael O’Hare was dealing with at the time.

    #264783
    Warbodog
    Participant

    Stargate was my Star Trek replacement after DS9 ended. I thought the early, naive years were loads of fun, but I got less interested around season 5/6. Then I moved on to Farscape, which was the most entertaining epic sci-fi sitcom until Moffat/Smith Doctor Who came along.

    #264813

    it becomes only more impressive when you learn what Michael O’Hare was dealing with at the time.

    I’m glad I didn’t see it until after his death, because I would have been really annoyed about him leaving before it all got explained. The whole thing is really tragic.

    Stargate was my Star Trek replacement after DS9 ended. I thought the early, naive years were loads of fun, but I got less interested around season 5/6.

    I think the first series is pretty naff, suffering from the kind of generic sci-fi stories that most first series tend to, but after that it gets pretty good. I think it lost a little something around the time Daniel left and never quite recovered, although I do like the Ben Browder & Claudia Black series at the back end. Speaking of…

    Then I moved on to Farscape, which was the most entertaining epic sci-fi sitcom until Moffat/Smith Doctor Who came along.

    Yeah, an absolute gem and one of my all-time favourite shows.

    #264832

    I used to really enjoy Farscape when it went out when I was in my teens. But twice I’ve tried to re-watch it since and I never get to the end of series 1

    #264837
    Warbodog
    Participant

    To skip the growing pains, you could start from episode 16 or the 19-20 two-parter if you don’t need much backstory. Then if you still don’t like those, probably forget it.

    I did find that it was less amazing when I watched it again five years ago. Probably more my taste changing than any fault of the show.

    #264840
    GlenTokyo
    Participant

    I hated Farscape when it was on, just couldn’t get on with it. During the first Covid lockdown though I was looking for stuff to watch and Farscape popped up – series 1 is great, but I lost interest during series 2 because it just seemed like they threw the dynamics from series 1 in the bin and did something else.

    #264841
    Jonathan Capps
    Keymaster

    it becomes only more impressive when you learn what Michael O’Hare was dealing with at the time

    #264842
    RunawayTrain
    Participant

    I think it took me 3 tries to get into Farscape, I have no idea why, but once I did, I was gripped! Absolutely brilliant. You forget the puppets are not real people quite quickly, they’re so well done. I haven’t watched it for a while though other than the odd standalone ep, simply because I haven’t had the emotional energy. (Same with DS9.)

    I rewatched series 9 and 10 of SG-1 recently but wasn’t in the right frame of mind to start from the beginning, and am currently going through Atlantis – for some reason that’s a lot easier to pick up, maybe because it’s from an established universe and they pretty much know what they’re doing from the start (in terms of gate travel, anyway!).

    #264843

    I struggled a bit with Atlantis. I think I just find Space Vampires a really, really uninteresting choice of enemy. I probably got halfway through the second series before giving up. Annoyingly, although it doesn’t come close to Arrowverse level, there are a handful of things in Atlantis which do have an effect on SG-1, so I remember a couple of times when I realised I’d missed something.

    #264855
    Jenuall
    Participant

    Farscape lost me around the time Scorpio (is that the bad guys name?) ended up inside a chip in Chrichton’s head or whatever it was. Actually that may not be true, I think conceptually that was interesting at first but it seemed to drag on too long if I recall rightly

    #264870
    Hamish
    Participant

    I’m glad I didn’t see it until after his death, because I would have been really annoyed about him leaving before it all got explained. The whole thing is really tragic.

    Just imagine having to film an episode like “And the Sky Full of Stars” when you actually have been hallucinating on set.

    #264872
    Warbodog
    Participant

    I was enjoying B5’s classic sci-fi allegories until the ‘pro-Earth’ anti-alien violence arc made it as escapist as watching This Is England. I don’t know how old-school sci-fi viewers/readers handled Cold War parables week after week. Good show, anyway.

    #264873
    Jonathan Capps
    Keymaster

    I was enjoying B5’s classic sci-fi allegories until the ‘pro-Earth’ anti-alien violence arc made it as escapist as watching This Is England. I don’t know how old-school sci-fi viewers/readers handled Cold War parables week after week. Good show, anyway.

    “We can’t act the Universe’s policemen, Senator!”

    *winks to camera*

Viewing 50 posts - 1 through 50 (of 64 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.