Home › Forums › Ganymede & Titan Forum › Ace Rimmer – What A Bastard

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #320486
    Dave
    Participant

    Time for a long-overdue reappraisal of whether Ace is actually a nice guy or not.

Viewing 41 replies - 1 through 41 (of 41 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #320487
    Dave
    Participant

    This is a dickheaded thing to say.

    #320488
    Dave
    Participant

    Not very understanding, Ace.

    #320489
    Dave
    Participant

    Taken together, this implies that after meeting Cat and learning he doesn’t have a name, Ace still thinks it’s more important to give Lister a nickname than sort out a proper name for Cat. What an arsehole.

    #320491
    Dave
    Participant

    Sexually harassing a woman and implicitly conditioning her rescue from her Nazi captors on future payment in kind. NOT OK, ACE.

    #320492
    Dave
    Participant

    And of course the all-time number one.

    #320494
    Warbodog
    Participant

    I remember in this otherwise thoughtful episode ranking (at 26:00, maybe the same guy who made the Tiermaker template), he seemed to treat Ace Rimmer as if the show was sincerely selling him as a perfect role model and not a parody. Though you can still get a joke and hate it at the same time too.

    I feel like this may have been common for both the love and hate extremes. Dimension Jump’s one of my favourites, but he’s clearly a tool.

    #320495
    Ben Saunders
    Participant

    But Rimmer is a weaselly maggot who probably can’t smoke a kipper. Ace considers giving somebody a nickname a great honour, and Cat already has one, so giving him another one is redundant. He says “hopefully” some sex, which is just a very forward way of asking for consent. And mechanoids aren’t people, so decking one is fine. Please remove this inflammatory post immediately.

    #320496

    Doesn’t he know it’s the height of bad manners to turn down the offer of sex?

    #320498
    loadoftottnumb
    Participant

    This is very similar to the Butler debate, whom I personally consider an insufferable smug Polaroid Head. 

    Ace is no saint, he’s still Rimmer, just Rimmer with confidence. 

    #320499
    Dave
    Participant

    But Rimmer is a weaselly maggot who probably can’t smoke a kipper. Ace considers giving somebody a nickname a great honour, and Cat already has one, so giving him another one is redundant. He says “hopefully” some sex, which is just a very forward way of asking for consent. And mechanoids aren’t people, so decking one is fine. Please remove this inflammatory post immediately.

    ACE APOLOGIST

    #320500

    I said it once before but I still maintain Ace is a little homophobic 

    #320502
    Ben Saunders
    Participant

    So is Rimmer to be fair, therefore it’s in his DNA and arguably not his fault. Ace vindicated again

    #320506

    So is Rimmer to be fair, therefore it’s in his DNA and arguably not his fault. Ace vindicated again

    Doesn’t this just excuse every homophobe ever?

    #320509
    tombow
    Participant

    I’ve said it before, but I think Dimension Jump would have been more powerful if Ace actually looked and sounded anything like “normal” Rimmer. Say if he was just normal Rimmer with more self confidence and a kinder personality. Him looking and sounding so different takes away from the concept that he’s someone our Rimmer could have been, imo. In fact, I wonder if the episode would still work if he wasn’t even Rimmer – just a travelling space hero (played by Rik Mayall or someone) who Rimmer hates for being everything he wants to be.

    Or what if he’d been Rimmer’s brother, and genuinely remorseful? Like he tries to say “I’m sorry, Arnie. Father tried to turn us against each other. I should have been a better brother to you” and you can see he’s done a lot of work on himself and become a better person, and the rest of the crew love him, but Rimmer just doesn’t care about his apologies and just wants revenge. And as you watch you’re on his side, because you can see how much he wants to make amends, but Rimmer is too bitter (not fully my idea, something similar happens in the NZ comedy film Eagle vs Shark. In fact, in that film, the former victim’s petty revenge on the remorseful former bully is even darker)

    #320514
    Jonathan Capps
    Keymaster

    Are you sure you’ve exhausted absolutely all of your possibilities before you gleefully go for the “murder cat” option, you prick?

    #320520
    Rushy
    Participant

    This is a dickheaded thing to say.

    Even the best people end up responding to negative energy with negative energy. 

    #320527
    Moonlight
    Participant

    Ace is just rubbing it in how useless he thinks Rimmer is by asking to perform a task he is physically incapable of and then mocking him for it.

    That said, between this and the original ending I think Rob and Doug might’ve just forgotten Rimmer is a hologram while writing this episode.

    #320534
    Dave
    Participant

    Ace is just rubbing it in how useless he thinks Rimmer is by asking to perform a task he is physically incapable of and then mocking him for it.

    That said, between this and the original ending I think Rob and Doug might’ve just forgotten Rimmer is a hologram while writing this episode.

    Reminiscent of the bit in Backwards (the novel) where he eventually learns how to control something physical by bouncing his light bee on it.

    #320540
    Rushy
    Participant

    Reminiscent of the bit in Backwards (the novel) where he eventually learns how to control something physical by bouncing his light bee on it.

    Could’ve done a great reverse Polymorph joke with that, with Rimmer’s hologram humping the console to get it to work

    #320541
    Warbodog
    Participant

    That idea only occurred to Ace because he was always putting his balls on stuff unsolicited.

    #320615
    Ian Symes
    Keymaster

    #320644
    Nick R
    Participant

    Are you sure you’ve exhausted absolutely all of your possibilities before you gleefully go for the “murder cat” option, you prick?

    As much as they look and sound alike, Emohawk’d Rimmer is not Ace Rimmer!

    Arnold has had certain negative emotions/personality traits completely removed by the Emohawk. Whereas Ace would still have access to those emotions, he just doesn’t act on them.

    So we can’t look at what Arnold does in E:PII and assume that Ace would behave the same!

    #320648
    Flap Jack
    Participant

    As much as they look and sound alike, Emohawk’d Rimmer is not Ace Rimmer!

    Yes, but the Emohawk has turned him into an Ace even if he’s not the Ace. If Emohawk Ace doesn’t count, then neither should Stoke Ace.

    #320649
    Ben Saunders
    Participant

    #NotMyAce

    #320650
    Dave
    Participant

    #320678
    Professor Flibble
    Participant

    I think Ace Rimmer is sort of an idea made form with a long, flowy wig and lots of confidence anyway, so I’d personally count any depiction of Ace Rimmer as, well, an Ace Rimmer. 

    #320703

    This version of Ace is a bit of a prick

    funny to think Rimmer got the same nickname at school but for entirely different reasons 

    Ace – because he’s ace

    Rimmer – ironically, because he is a complete melt

    #320707
    Warbodog
    Participant

    I don’t think it really counts as your nickname if you’re the only one using it.

    #320737
    Moonlight
    Participant

    #320753
    Rushy
    Participant

    I was honestly ready for a Rimmer prequel series with these two

    #321871
    Warbodog
    Participant

    Racist.

    #321926
    Moonlight
    Participant

    He abuses a confused animal.

    #321929
    Dave
    Participant

    #321931
    Warbodog
    Participant

    Indiscreet about colleagues’ private lives and kinks.

    #321961
    Paul Muller
    Participant

    #321962

    #321970
    Rudolph
    Participant

    As much as they look and sound alike, Emohawk’d Rimmer is not Ace Rimmer!
    Yes, but the Emohawk has turned him into an Ace even if he’s not the Ace. If Emohawk Ace doesn’t count, then neither should Stoke Ace.

    #321978

    Is Emohawk Ace just Captain Platini?

    #321981
    Warbodog
    Participant

    Is Emohawk Ace just Captain Platini?

    Especially when he’s Air-Cooled.

    #321982

    If my quick search in Smegadrive is right, he is never referred to as Ace in the Emohawk, so that he is Platini so my new headcanon 

    #321988
    Flap Jack
    Participant

    FAN THEORY: 

    He’s Rimmer.

Viewing 41 replies - 1 through 41 (of 41 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.