Should Series I have kept the original ending to Only the Good?

[flanl3]

Should the original ending to Only the Good… have been the way they end up with almost nobody on board in the first episode?

Also, related:

Should Rob Grant have been brought on instead of Kochanski as a crewmember in Series VII, but have been written the same? How would the show be different if Rob Grant and Lister were Lister’s parents?

Should every episode have ended in the exact same way as Tikka to Ride?

Should the Polaroid on the end credits of Future Echoes have been a double Polaroid instead?

Topic

[International Debris]

Bloody hell XII had better hurry up.

[Manbird]

Tom Hardy as Rob Grant.

[Rival Schools]

If Rob Grant was confectionary, he’d be a Marathon bar.

[bloodteller]

if Doug Naylor was confectionary, he’d be a bag of Revels

[Moonlight]

Should every episode have ended in the exact same way as Tikka to Ride?

You mean Lister being beaten to death or Lister being left to die from starvation as soon as the curry goes bad?

[bloodteller]

“Look out Earth, the slime’s coming home!”

*Rimmer and Cat look at Lister in disgust, and then violently stamp on his head and beat the shit out of him with truncheons*

[Rival Schools]

Those weren’t truncheons.

[Ben Saunders]

>if Doug Naylor was confectionary, he’d be a bag of Revels
Pretty good, but every now and then you get a coffee one and want to die? Good analogy

[Author]

Replies