Home › Forums › Ganymede & Titan Forum › Russell Two Davies

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #269466
    Nick R
    Participant

    Apparently, today there was some news about a change to Doctor Who’s production staff, in some obscure behind-the-scenes role. I don’t know if anyone else heard about it?

Viewing 35 replies - 1,451 through 1,485 (of 1,485 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #328083
    Rushy
    Participant

    It’s interesting how Tennant basically just inherited everything from Eccleston and just got on with it. 

    It was important to establish that

    A) it was the same character (for the audience)

    and

    B) the show doesn’t need to be tied to its star (for the BBC)

    Remember, the BBC seriously considered cancelling the show because Tennant left. If he’d been there from series 1, they actually might have. 

    #328086
    Ben Saunders
    Participant

    It’s quite strange when Billie comes back as (pre?) S1 Rose in The End of Time, because she looked so radically different by that point. A bit like when they do a flashback in one of the Saw movies and it’s just the old guy with a backwards cap on. But not quite that bad.

    #328087
    Renegade Rob
    Participant

    They show the end of Parting of the Ways with Rose and then after the titles they cut back and she’s in the same clothes but her face is made up like it was in S2 and her hair is noticeably much closer to S2 hair. They did their best to extend it to make it look closer to her S1 hair, but it’s noticeable. It’s supposed to be the exact scene seconds after we see her at the end of S1. It’s not as bad as Kochanski with a new hairstyle in the start of VIII when they fly into Red Dwarf, but it’s not great (I guess the Nanobots messed with her hair as well?). 

    #328088
    Rushy
    Participant

    A bit like when they do a flashback in one of the Saw movies and it’s just the old guy with a backwards cap on.

    He’s not wearing the backwards cap to imply de-aging. He’s wearing it because he’s pretending to be an idiot fan of a pretentious author. 

    #328089
    Ben Saunders
    Participant

    He’s not wearing the backwards cap to imply de-aging. He’s wearing it because he’s pretending to be an idiot fan of a pretentious author. 

    I’ll be honest, I’ve seen Saw 1 and 2 and maybe 3. I only know what internet memes have told me about the later ones.

    #328092
    Renegade Rob
    Participant

    #328095
    Flap Jack
    Participant

    So it’s basically a Back to the Future situation. At least Billie didn’t get replaced with Elisabeth Shue.

    Personally though I never really noticed the discontinuity going from The Parting of the Ways to Untitled 2005 Children in Need Special.

    The one I did notice was Doomsday to The Runaway Bride, when Donna appears in the TARDIS. In Doomsday the whole set is bathed in green light, but in the Runaway Bride it’s just standard white light.

    So if you’re reading this, uh…. (looks up the Directory of Photography on The Runaway Bride) RORY TAYLOR, you absolutely fucked that.

    #328096
    Professor Flibble
    Participant

    They had to reshoot the scene and everything, which AFAIK has only happened two other times in New Who (Twice Upon A Time and Space Babies). 

    I once did an edit where I cut from Tennant walking across the set in Doomsday to a shot of the time rotor with the lighting getting brighter, then to the Runaway Bride version of the scene. 

    #328097
    Rushy
    Participant

    I never noticed it as a kid, but in retrospect, I much prefer the mood lighting of series 1-2. 

    #328098
    Professor Flibble
    Participant

    It flatters the set but I’m not really keen on the Doctor’s TARDIS console room having dark lighting because it looks uninviting. Dim lighting like in Capaldi’s era is fine but the Series 1 and 2 lighting is intensely dark and green. Much preferred the Series 3 and 4 lighting tbh.

    #328099
    Renegade Rob
    Participant

    The Doomsday-to-Runaway Bride lighting differential wasn’t a continuity error, just the Doppler effect, since the TARDIS was in mid-flight when Donna warped in and was in the process of fluctuating time vectors at that moment. So when it was going to the past it had a greenish light from a blue shift and the warmer whiter light was the red shift when it was phasing into the future.  

    #328100
    Rushy
    Participant

    It flatters the set but I’m not really keen on the Doctor’s TARDIS console room having dark lighting because it looks uninviting. Dim lighting like in Capaldi’s era is fine but the Series 1 and 2 lighting is intensely dark and green.

    More alien, though

    #328119
    Ben Saunders
    Participant

    We could have gotten another irreconcilable origin story for an Earthly event like how we have three separate Atlantis stories. Properly classic stuff.

    #328125
    Technopeasant
    Participant

    So Five starts it for Fifteen to get caught up in it?

    #328146
    Rudolph
    Participant

    #328147
    Warbodog
    Participant

    #328148
    Dave
    Participant

    #328265
    Professor Flibble
    Participant

    Shame we missed out on an epic four part Dalek story for Ncuti but thank god we didn’t get more War Between series.

    Really dodged a bullet there. Why does every Doctor Who spin-off have to be based on the premise “what happens to Earth when the Doctor isn’t there?” Sod that. Expand the universe. Give us Abslom Daak: The Movie. Game of Thrones but it’s Peladon. A live-action Dalek Empire. And a McGann series.

    #328270
    Rushy
    Participant

    Why does every Doctor Who spin-off have to be based on the premise “what happens to Earth when the Doctor isn’t there?”

    Doctor Who’s anthological nature works against spinoffs. The franchise has never bothered to develop much of an internal logic. Which is why most spinoffs default to “what if X character from X story also went on to fight monsters every week?”

    I’ll give War Between some credit in that it’s going for a (marginally) more original premise, I just wish it wasn’t shit. 

    #328271
    Dave
    Participant

    I can’t believe we didn’t ever get a Paternoster Gang spinoff, it seemed like the characters were designed for that.

    #328272
    Ben Saunders
    Participant

    At least we got Class. Did anyone watch Class?

    War Between had potential but they managed to make it really boring and really stupid at the same time. Remember when they killed every dog on the planet? Will there be no dogs in the Whoniverse going forward?

    #328273
    Rushy
    Participant

    I can’t believe we didn’t ever get a Paternoster Gang spinoff, it seemed like the characters were designed for that.

    That’s why I’m glad we didn’t get it. Their episodes were such a transparent backdoor pilot for something that had no legs. 

    #328274
    Nick R
    Participant

    At least we got Class. Did anyone watch Class?

    #328275
    Rushy
    Participant

    I watched the first episode for Capaldi’s guest appearance. I didn’t care for the new characters, but he was nice as always. And I liked the return of Flavia’s theme in the score. 

    #328276
    Ian Symes
    Keymaster

    Let’s not pretend The Sarah Jane Adventures didn’t exist and wasn’t by far the best spin-off the show’s ever had.

    #328277
    Ben Saunders
    Participant

    SJA was pretty good, I avoided it for being kiddy shit but in more recent years I caught a few episodes and was pleasantly surprised at how strong some of the storytelling was. Liz Sladen was a treasure.

    Torchwood I also caught when they streamed it on Twitch a few years ago, I remember thinking it was alright, bit needlessly grim and sexual to try and differentiate itself from Doctor Who and prove this is a Show For Adults I thought. Just as the show was starting to get good in season one they did that abysmal finale where Jack shouts at a massive CGI devil or something. Miracle Day had promise but was ssssssssssoooooooooo slow, I did like the episode where Captain Jack has gratuitous gay sex with some guy in the past though, actually.

    #328278
    cwickham
    Participant

    Even if the Moffat era had the bandwidth to produce a spin-off, I don’t think the Paternosters were ever developed enough as characters to make one work.

    #328280
    Professor Flibble
    Participant

    Let’s not pretend The Sarah Jane Adventures didn’t exist and wasn’t by far the best spin-off the show’s ever had.

    Oh, absolutely. There’s a lot about it I wish the New Series did, like the serial format and the cliffhangers. But it’s sort of, I wish it was the one show with that premise because Doctor Who has a lot of untapped potential as a franchise.

    #328281
    Professor Flibble
    Participant

    Doctor Who’s anthological nature works against spinoffs. The franchise has never bothered to develop much of an internal logic. Which is why most spinoffs default to “what if X character from X story also went on to fight monsters every week?”

    But I don’t think it needs to, if each series works on its own. Theoretically, most Doctor Who stories could be pilot episodes for series about the worlds they’re set in and the characters they feature in.

    #328282
    Flap Jack
    Participant

    The Paternoster Gang is like backfiring worldbuilding. In A Good Man Goes to War the fact that The Doctor had a bunch of friends we’d never heard of to come to his aid painted a picture of how expensive his life and adventures are off-screen. But then when they kept coming back it was like, oh, OK, no, he actually doesn’t have a huge expanse of off-screen friends from unseen adventures, it’s literally just these guys. Suddenly the world felt weirdly small.

    I did enjoy them as characters though, putting aside the fact that Strax’s “what if a Sontaran were a fucking idiot” shtick got tiresome relatively quickly.

    Also they did literally get a spin-off at Big Finish but I guess we’re not counting that.

    #328283
    Professor Flibble
    Participant

    Oh yeah, for the sake of argument, not counting Big Finish. 

    #328284
    Renegade Rob
    Participant

    This is probably just me but no matter how good a spin-off is in the Doctor Who universe, its inherent fluctuating timeline means that the spin-offs feel essentially unmoored and irrelevant (and I say that as someone who loved the Sarah Jane Adventures and possibly teared up during that lovely funeral epilogue they made during the lockdown). Time is a wibbly-wobbly ball where Captain Jack can spin-off and deal with Miracle Day (which gets zero acknowledgement in the parent series) and then casually pop in way later to hang out with the Thirteenth Doctor. Contrast that with Star Wars or the MCU, which have “hard” timelines meaning even the worst spin-offs feel more relevant since they have to be reconciled with other stories in that universe. Doctor Who’s inconsistent enough with how much the rest of the Doctor’s adventures have lingered in the “present” timeline, to the point where things only feel canon/relevant if the Doctor himself experienced them, since the timeline is constantly changing anyway, and as a result spin-off characters feel less vital the second they split off into the fluctuating abyss. 

    #328294
    Ian Symes
    Keymaster

    Oh, absolutely. There’s a lot about it I wish the New Series did, like the serial format and the cliffhangers. But it’s sort of, I wish it was the one show with that premise because Doctor Who has a lot of untapped potential as a franchise.

    I don’t think The One Show would work with that premise. Alex Jones and Roman Kemp fighting off alien invasions from a house in Ealing?

    #328311
    Professor Flibble
    Participant

    Oh I don’t know, The One Show seems like it’s about anything.

    Meant the one spin-off, should’ve clarified. SJA is the one really good one, K-9 and Company is an interesting footnote, Torchwood I can give or take, K-9, eh, Class…pfft. Didn’t care for War Between, wanted a McGann series instead. You have 5 episodes of a deal going to a spin-off, give them to McGann.

    #328327
    Technopeasant
    Participant

    K-9 and Company

    Vague excuse to post this unlocked.

Viewing 35 replies - 1,451 through 1,485 (of 1,485 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.